I realize that not everyone wants to recycle and that at least here in New York, it is required and landlords can get fines for having recyclables in the trash. So there are those of us who feel pushed to recycle by the government, and those of us who feel compelled by our own internal need to make a positive impact on the world to recycle. Then there are those who are simply afraid of getting a fine and who, rather than learn the rules, throw every possible piece of plastic into a clear bag and chuck it onto the sidewalk (including landlords I know of who go through their tenants’ trash and put non-recyclables into the tenants’ recycling bags!) In the end though, no matter how one feels about recycling, the truth is that most of us are required to do it, so why spend energy doing it incorrectly when it’s not that hard to do it correctly? Following are a list of common mistakes I see all the time in my neighborhood and the simple ways we can remedy them.

1. Wrong kind of bag or bin.
Frankly, our trash and recycling guys have a rough job for obvious reasons. So it’s no wonder that when items are in the wrong kind of bag the guys either leave it on the sidewalk or throw it in the trash truck. Best way to get your recyclables on a trash truck? Put them in a white semi-clear trash bag. Sounds like a no-brainer, but I actually see this a lot on the street; white semi-opaque bags with all kinds of cans and bottles pressed up into the plastic, left behind with all the bags of trash when there’s clearly recyclables inside. (Interestingly, we have started using compostable trash bags at our apartment, which are light green, and we are finding that they don’t get picked up with the trash. The color must be confusing the trash guys.)
Long story short: Use clear bags for paper, light blue or clear bags for plastic, metal, and glass. Don’t use trash bags for anything but trash.

This is what a clear plastic bag looks like. Happy.
2. Incorrect items in the bag or bin.
This is my gigantic pet peeve. In Brooklyn, everything is literally out on the sidewalk in plain view on recycling day, and 9 bags out of 10 clearly have many items in them that New York City does not recycle (take-out containers of all stripes and yogurt containers being the most prominent). I have heard a rumor that if a bag contains inappropriate items, the city will just throw the whole bag away because they don’t have the person-power to sort through the mess. (Clarification of that rumor is reserved for a later post.) It really doesn’t take much effort or research to find out what belongs in your recycling bin or bag. Do it New York! And you too, everyone else!
3. Using your neighbor’s bag or bin as a guideline as to what should be in yours.
Don’t assume that your neighbor knows what they are doing. If you are unsure, do your own research. Go to the above links, print out any relevant information and keep it near your household recycling containers or taped to your refrigerator. It’s easy to forget what goes where and what is accepted and what isn’t. Keep the info handy and you won’t have to think about it.
4. Dirty bottles, cans, and containers.
Every location is probably a little different in this regard. In New York, metal cans and plastic food bottles (that have a neck smaller than the rest of the bottle) need to be rinsed but not spotless. That means a little bit of cat food stuck to the inner lip of the can = OK. That half-full can of Spaghettios and the moldy bottle of juice with OJ goo at the bottom = NOT OK.
If you have pick up for other plastics like 1, 2, 4, and 5 (or if you have places to drop them off) the number usually indicates the needed level of cleanliness. Your item needs to be either spotless (this mostly applies to number 5, i.e. yogurt containers, etc) or at least passably clean, meaning that you rinsed it and got all the food chunks off. A little bit of food here and there on the numbers 1, 2, and 4 won’t keep them from being recycled, but take the time to at least clean enough that you can clearly see the number on the item! (never mind that sometimes you need a magnifying glass as well…)
How do you clean a yogurt container so it’s spotless? Use a knife (carefully) to remove all of the foil from the top and use a degreaser such as Citrasolve to remove any remaining yogurt. If you have pets, cat and dog hairs will affix themselves to your clean yogurt cups as if magnetized. Once you clean your number 5’s, tie them up tightly in a plastic bag and you won’t have to clean them again.
5. Unbundled magazines and unbundled cardboard.
There is a reason the city (and lots of towns across the country as well) ask that cardboard and newspaper be bundled and tied with twine. It facilitates pick-up and future sorting. A lot of bags and items get thrown into one big truck (at least here in Brooklyn); no one wants to dig through all that to put your scattered pile of Rolling Stone and Details magazines all in the right place. Also, if you don’t bundle, magazines and especially newspapers will end up in the street and in the neighbor’s yard. Add a little rain and wind to the mix and you have a pretty big mess. Also, most in most places you can put all your magazines and different kinds of paper in a clear recycling bag and be done with it. And yes, New York does take envelopes with the plastic windows in them. You don’t need to spend any time ripping them out.
6. Recycling bags that have been ripped open for returnables or other attractive items.
Depending on where you live and who’s going through your garbage and for what reason, it’s not uncommon to find your recycling bag ripped open, the contents spilled onto the sidewalk, and the returnables gone. Easy solution: Put the returnables in a separate clear bag or open box for those who need them to take. Makes everyone’s lives a little bit easier.

How not to recycle.
7. Bins that have been filled with trash or improper items.
I personally don’t know much about bins because we don’t use them in Brooklyn. However, I do see lots of trash thrown into recycling cans since passers-by can’t be bothered to throw their trash into either a public can or at least the correct kind of can. Three ideas come to mind to remedy this.
- If you use a can, bag your recyclables instead of putting them directly in the can.
- Cover your bin or can. People are far less likely to throw their trash onto the lid of a covered bin.
- Put your bins or cans out right before the recycling people are scheduled to come, and bring them back in once they’ve been emptied. (This is a little hard to do in New York since the pick up is usually at some ridiculous hour, like 3:00 a.m.)
8. Plastics that end up in the trash.
So let’s say you are following all the recycling rules for your city or town and you realize that all those food containers you used to put out are not actually recyclable. Check to see if they have numbers on them. If not, they probably do belong in the trash if they can’t be reused in some way. But numbers 1,2, 4, and 5, for example, can be recycled depending on where you live.
We have a coop in Park Slope that takes plastics with those numbers (as long as they are not bottle shaped; the city takes those) and the coop has an agreement with companies that take the plastics and reuse them. For example, one company takes number 5’s and makes plastic lumber and park benches out of them. Do a little research and you might find a similar program in your town.
I’m happy to announce Preserve’s Gimme 5 Program for taking back any plastics with the 5 stamped on them (as long as they are clean!) This may be as easy as taking your 5 plastics to a participating Whole Foods. Go here for info and regs, and here for an article about it by our friends at Planet Green.
9. Buying items that will need to be thrown away, when there is a recyclable alternative.
The easiest one I know? Toothbrushes! If you get your toothbrushes from Preserve, you can mail them back (for free!) to the company when you are done and the handle is repurposed. And even better; the toothbrushes are originally made from yogurt containers. (Send me your favorite recycled/recyclable household items list. I’d love to hear it!)
10. Not paying attention.
This is pretty much the crux of recycling properly: we have to pay attention. It may take a little more effort and wakefulness to do the research, to bundle the items, to make sure we have the right numbers, etc., but why should we bother to recycle if we are not going to do it properly? Why should we bother to clean a plastic that is not recyclable and then put it in a clear bag when it could actually hinder the process? It is definitely worth it to stay on top of the recycling rules and alternatives where we live. More and more companies are finding ways to recycle used materials, so let’s do our part and pay attention!